Gherald is pretty dead-set on believing that the “Cash for Clunkers” program was a wasteful, ineffective boondoggle. Leaving aside my baseline argument against that,* I wanted to post in a decent explanation of one of the primary reasons I consider the program’s outcome to be largely effective:
Was there waste? Sure. Could we have pumped in money to another sector to boost spending? Sure. But when we ponder what appears to be a decent nudge to improving perceptions about the economy, I think the signs are positive and we probably even got a pretty good bang for our buck.
For my money, though, the uncounted benefit of the program has been its effect on the intangible economic force John Maynard Keynes calls “animal spirits.” For weeks, the news and blogosphere have been loaded with images of busy car salespeople explaining that they were selling out of the Ford Focus (when did you think you’d hear that?). Car shoppers appeared on camera with an acquisitive gleam in their eyes that has been in hiding since 2007. And we were treated to the vision of a federal stimulus program that actually seemed to be working. If you wanted to persuade consumers that the economy really is starting to recover, you couldn’t buy more convincing advertising.
Animal spirits, by their nature, aren’t easily measured. But Tuesday’s consumer confidence survey results did register a far greater rebound in optimism than economists expected. (The survey was taken in early to mid-August, when it was becoming clear that Cash for Clunkers would burn through another $2 billion, easy.) Interestingly, consumers say they believe that the economy is still in terrible shape. But their faith in the future has risen to levels not seen since before the recession began. Faith doesn’t easily yield to a cost-benefit analysis, but It’s hard to overstate its economic importance, as Nobel prize-winning economist George Akerlof points out in this MoneyWatch.com video.
Obviously, Cash for Clunkers didn’t account entirely for the jump in consumer confidence, and there’s no guarantee that it won’t fade again, especially if unemployment refuses to fall. And while confidence can’t cause a recovery, a recovery can’t happen without it. So to the extent that the clunkers program gave Americans a reason to believe that things can eventually return to normal and to have some faith that government has a handle on recovery, it was a pretty good investment.
* – I.e., The program was designed to pump billions of dollars into the economy to boost spending and consumer and business sentiment. It did just that without producing any significant negative externalities. Ergo, CFC’s outcome doesn’t meet the definition of “failure“.
President Obama announced that he is going to end a decades-old monstrosity from the early days of Jesse Helms-inspired (may he rot in the hell I don’t believe in) AIDS hysteria:
A couple of years ago Michelle and I were in Africa and we tried to combat the stigma when we were in Kenya by taking a public HIV/AIDS test. And I’m proud to announce today we’re about to take another step towards ending that stigma.Thank goodness for meaningful change that makes a difference in people’s lives.
Twenty-two years ago, in a decision rooted in fear rather than fact, the United States instituted a travel ban on entry into the country for people living with HIV/AIDS. Now, we talk about reducing the stigma of this disease — yet we’ve treated a visitor living with it as a threat. We lead the world when it comes to helping stem the AIDS pandemic — yet we are one of only a dozen countries that still bar people from HIV from entering our own country.If we want to be the global leader in combating HIV/AIDS, we need to act like it.
And that’s why, on Monday my administration will publish a final rule that eliminates the travel ban effective just after the New Year. Congress and President Bush began this process last year, and they ought to be commended for it. We are finishing the job. It’s a step that will encourage people to get tested and get treatment, it’s a step that will keep families together, and it’s a step that will save lives.
Claiming that the president was preying on the public’s fear of contracting a fatal disease last week when he declared the H1N1 virus a national emergency, Republican leaders announced Wednesday that they were officially endorsing the swine flu.
“Thousands of Americans—hardworking ordinary Americans like you and me—already have H1N1,” Republican National Committee chairman Michael Steele said during a press conference. “Now Obama wants to take that away from us. Ask yourself: Do you want the federal government making these kinds of health care decisions for you and your family?”
Other prominent Republicans opposing Obama’s declaration of emergency include Louisiana governor Bobby Jindal, who urged residents of his state to continue not washing their hands.
Entirely predictable news…
With 85% of 1st time home buyers who were eligible to collect the tax credit planning to buy a home anyway, the Brookings institute estimates that the $8,000 credit equates to a cost to the taxpayer of $43,000 per home. This is based on the belief that 85% of the almost 2mm buyers are getting free money. Edmonds.com…is estimating that the Cash for Clunkers program cost taxpayers $24,000 per vehicle sold. They estimate that 82% of sales would have happened anyway and thus the handout of up to $4,500 really only enticed 18% of the buyers of 690k vehicles sold under the program.I’m curious to know whether any readers here dispute such figures, or still believe—despite the grave waste previously discussed—that C4C was, somehow, an economically or environmentally sound and efficient stimulus.
…rather than a wasteful but politically popular program which merely succeeded in pleasing misguided leftists, new car buyers, and dealers—as it appears to me.
More of this please:
The annual American Bankers Association meeting in Chicago is not going as planned.
Besieged by activists from the Service Employees International Union, the AFL-CIO and Americans for Financial Reform, the leaders of America’s financial sector were interrupted Sunday night as a throng of protesters poured into the conference area and began to chant.
The meeting, scheduled to continue through Tuesday, will feature “[exceptional] speakers like FDIC Chairman Sheila Bair, Comptroller of the Currency John Dugan, former Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich, and political commentator George Will,” the ABA’s site announced.
“All we wanted to do was deliver a letter to the Wall Street bankers to let them know how much they’ve hurt our communities – and what they need to do to clean up their act,” the SEIU’s blog declared. “They wouldn’t listen to us. They kicked us out. But the bad news for them is that we’ll be back.
Instead of delivering a letter, they shouted their message. “Bust up big banks!” activists chanted. When police confronted a senior who was damning the ABA over a loudspeaker, the crowd shifted into cries of “Shame on you! Shame on you!“
When police finally got around to pushing them out, cheers of “We’ll be back” shook the hotel’s lobby.
“Our demand is simple: stop taking our tax dollars and squandering them away on billion dollar bonuses and massive lobbying campaigns against financial reform,” the SEIU said.
- Yes Means Yes (1)
- Not AWOL Exactly… (1)
- Never Gonna End (2)
- Prequels (1)
- Fox News Has a First Amendment Right to Lie – Updated (87)
- At Least Something Good Comes Out Of The Zimmerman Trial (7)
- The Spiritual Masochism Of Perpetual Victimhood (4)
- Fun With Etymology: Why Is An Earthquake a "Temblor"? (2)
- Quick Thoughts (1)
- Public Option Now in the Hands of (Eep!) Harry Reid
- Breaking! Sen. Richard Shelby's Nominee Shutdown Ransom Note Revealed!
- Shocker: The DOJ is Independent from the White House
- Watching Fox News Will Make You Even More Ignorant Than You Already Were
- Imperfect Non-illustration of rank GOP Hypocrisy
- NRCC: Time for McChrystal to Put Pelosi "In Her Place"
- Dangerous Building - Keep Out
- ThePoliticalBandit.com: Decisions That Led Up To Death Of Democracy In America
- Clown Town: The Moment of Impending Crisis
- » Faux News Inside Ponderance's Brain: 30;] that they make shit up, and had been shouting that since...
- Withholding Information from Congress |: Metavirus on 12 July 2009: Cheney Ordered CIA to Break the Law
- Mike Blessing's Heresies and Blasphemies: Comic-Con vs. Fred Phelps
- September 2014 (19)
- August 2014 (22)
- July 2014 (26)
- June 2014 (27)
- May 2014 (21)
- April 2014 (25)
- March 2014 (21)
- February 2014 (33)
- January 2014 (31)
- December 2013 (25)
- November 2013 (32)
- October 2013 (57)
- September 2013 (32)
- August 2013 (57)
- July 2013 (56)
- June 2013 (44)
- May 2013 (42)
- April 2013 (41)
- March 2013 (66)
- February 2013 (42)
- January 2013 (74)
- December 2012 (67)
- November 2012 (44)
- October 2012 (51)
- September 2012 (35)
- August 2012 (50)
- July 2012 (36)
- June 2012 (35)
- May 2012 (51)
- April 2012 (42)
- March 2012 (64)
- February 2012 (85)
- January 2012 (79)
- December 2011 (68)
- November 2011 (76)
- October 2011 (67)
- September 2011 (55)
- August 2011 (53)
- July 2011 (44)
- June 2011 (71)
- May 2011 (103)
- April 2011 (107)
- March 2011 (120)
- February 2011 (124)
- January 2011 (82)
- December 2010 (97)
- November 2010 (92)
- October 2010 (93)
- September 2010 (80)
- August 2010 (44)
- July 2010 (63)
- June 2010 (33)
- May 2010 (60)
- April 2010 (34)
- March 2010 (50)
- February 2010 (66)
- January 2010 (67)
- December 2009 (72)
- November 2009 (78)
- October 2009 (91)
- September 2009 (75)
- August 2009 (105)
- July 2009 (81)
- June 2009 (178)
- May 2009 (152)
- April 2009 (147)
- March 2009 (86)
- February 2009 (52)
- January 2009 (118)
- December 2008 (18)
Wine Labels2012 Election Abortion Barack Obama Bullshit Bush Christianity Congress Conservatives Corruption Debt Ceiling Democrats Economy Fail Foreign Policy Fox News Gay Marriage Hatred Health Care Ignorance Insanity Law LGBT Issues Libertarianism Lies Media Mitt Romney Music Policy Polls Quotes Racism Rebuttals Recession Republicans Right Wing Sarah Palin Scandal Stupidity Teabaggers Torture Truth Video War Crimes War on Drugs War on Terror